Local Tribunals for Hornsey Tottenham and Wood Green

Next post or  Back to the previous one

Most of the men associated with Hornsey, Tottenham and Wood Green appeared before one of the three local Military Service Tribunals. However, some who worked outside these areas appeared before the Tribunal where they worked.

Unfortunately, in 1921, the Ministry of Health ordered that all papers relating to individual cases of exemption, and all local MST minute books, should be destroyed as they were not considered of sufficient public value to justify preservation. The only exceptions were the Middlesex and Lothian appeals, which were to be preserved as examples. Recently a number of records have been discovered which survived the 1921 order and the National Archives produced a list of record offices holding these papers.

The three local tribunals for Hornsey, Tottenham and Wood Green were established in February of 1916 on advice and instructions of the Local Government Board. In view of the experience which they had already obtained the existing Local Tribunals, established under the Derby scheme, were to be modified to a minimum of seven members and to include an independent representative of the local working men as required by the Military Service Act.

Unlike the Derby scheme recruitment Tribunals, the Military Service Tribunals were concerned with hearing applications for exemption from military service.

Hornsey Military Service Tribunal for the Municipal Borough Council of Hornsey was held in the Town Hall on Southwood Lane Highgate.  It was set up as a panel of eight men; the Mayor, three Aldermen, two Councillors, one of whom was considered as adequate representation of working men, and two other men closely associated with the Council. All these men were prosperous figures and well known to the leading Councillors of the Borough. The absence of an independent representative of working men was eventually corrected, after well supported protest, to include a representative, nominated by the Hornsey Trades Council, of the local working men.

Tottenham Military Service Tribunal for the Tottenham Urban District Council was held in the Town Hall, Town Hall Approach Rd, Tottenham High Road. It was set up with eleven members, viz.: – the seven male members chosen for the Derby Scheme, and four others, one of whom was to be a woman – in this case the chairman’s wife – the remaining three were chosen from representatives of local Labour and Trades Council.

Wood Green Military Service Tribunal for the Wood Green Urban District Council was held in the Town Hall in the middle of Woodside Park, by Earlham Road. It  initially consisted of five councillors, one representative of the local labour force and one representative of employers. This eventually turned out to be too small for the work-load and had to be increased.

Each Local Tribunal also included a Military Representative, who as a full member, was the only individual who had the right of appeal against the Tribunal’s decision, of which they were a party to.

Next post or  Back to the previous one

17 thoughts on “Local Tribunals for Hornsey Tottenham and Wood Green

  1. Jennifer Bell June 6, 2019 at 9:49 am Reply

    John is right about the reluctance of the Hornsey Tribunal to have an adequate representative for the working people until it was more or less forced to. It is also worth noting that, apart from the Trades Council rep., all the Tribunal members were from the wealthy western part of Hornsey and none from the working class areas around Hornsey Village. In all my researches on Hornsey COs I found no reference to the Trades Council rep. having intervened in any discussion…..

    Liked by 1 person

  2. […] Hornsey, in 1916 when he applied for exemption from military service on grounds of conscience at Hornsey Tribunal.  They granted him exemption from combatant service conditional on his undertaking work of […]

    Like

  3. […] was a Bank Clerk who appeared before Tottenham Tribunal – he was given Exemption from Combatant Service conditional upon his doing Work of National […]

    Like

  4. […] as a Maintenance Engineer in Charge of a factory in 1916 (or 1917), when he first applied to Tottenham Tribunal for exemptionfrom military service. They gave him exemption from combatant service conditional on […]

    Like

  5. […] objectors. According to the Pearce Register, Christie, a GPO telegraphist, appeared before the Tottenham Tribunal, and his case was considered by the Pelham Committee in October 1916 and notes that the GPO wished […]

    Like

  6. […] Assuming that is correct he would have applied for an exemption from military service to the Tottenham Tribunal. We don’t know his reasons for not wanting to fight. He wasn’t a member of the Non-Combatant […]

    Like

  7. […] little is known about this man. According to the Pearce Register, Arthur, a clerk,  applied to Tottenham Tribunal for exemption from Military Service at some unspecified date. He was then referred to the Pelham […]

    Like

  8. […] motivation.   The Pearce Register lists him as a 29 year old warehouseman who he appeared before Tottenham Tribunal and the Middlesex Appeal Tribunal but there is no record of him in the Middlesex papers.  He may, […]

    Like

  9. […] Register that he was a Commercial Traveller, who was granted exemption from combatant service by Tottenham Military Service Tiribunal from combatant service conditional on his doing work of national importance to be allocated by the […]

    Like

  10. […] teacher. We don’t know why he became a conscientious objector but he was given exemption by Tottenham Tribunal conditional upon his doing Work of National Importance. He would have been referred to the Pelham […]

    Like

  11. […] the War, Walter had become a Cashier and applied to Tottenham Tribunal – he was granted exemption from combatant service.   Since he never appealed this result […]

    Like

  12. […] and was 18 when he applied for exemption from military service on conscientious grounds before Tottenham Tribunal some time in 1916.   We do not know what led him to apply, what his beliefs were, but he seems to […]

    Like

  13. […] this man.   He is recorded on the Pearce Register as a Motor Mechanic who appeared before the Tottenham Tribunal.  They gave him exemption from combatant service conditional upon his undertaking work of national […]

    Like

  14. […] April 1916 Sydney was granted exemption from combatant service by the Tottenham Military Service Tribunal but in May he appeals, the application again being made by W A Simpson, because a test case heard […]

    Like

  15. […] to the Pearce Register, at some point he must have come before the Tottenham Tribunal when he was working for the Inland Revenue as a clerk in the valuation office. We don’t know on […]

    Like

  16. […] we have no later address which ties him certainly to Tottenham, although he appeared before Tottenham MS Tribunal in 1916 and was given Exemption from Military Service conditional on Work of National Importance. […]

    Like

  17. […] a 21 year old, unmarried, manager in a stationary and printing business, who applied to Southgate Military Service Tribunal for exemption from military service as a conscientious objector on the 16 March 1916. The tribunal […]

    Like

Leave a comment